CoffeeCrew Blog

Eat Drink Love
Like there's no tomorrow
Because, hey, you never know.

In town eats Victoria - Pig BBQ versus Smoking Bones · 11.06.12 by colin newell

beer and espresso pork ribsIn a city seemingly built for meat eaters, there are a couple of stand outs – with a caveat or two. And they are Pig BBQ at the Atrium and Smoking Bones at the Hudson.

Chatting on the social network (twitter) today, I mused that in an active comparison between two of the more visible and successful smoked meat vendors, one of them kind of stood out.

But seeing how limited Twitter is for a truly meaningful conversation – or as a medium for getting ones complete opinion out, I offer this additional analysis.

To be fair, Pig BBQ (at the Atrium) and Smoking Bones at the Hudson are two completely different places doing two completely different things – with varying degrees of success.

On one hand, Pig BBQ is more of a no frills joint with semi-communal seating, order at the counter, take a seat and wait for your grub to be called out. What they do: pulled pork, pulled brisket, pulled chicken, specials like a yummy schnitzel sandwich or the frequent fried chicken on a waffle. Sides include palatable if slightly sweet baked beans and satisfying blocks of deep fried mac n’ cheese and the predictable corn bread and slaw. The digs are not fancy. In fact, they initially felt “cold” to me the first few visits. Repeated visits… well, I felt more at home.
Andrea and I can have a very satisfying quick lunch by sharing one sandwich, 1 mason jar of home brewed ice tea and two sides – typically the beans and the mac n’ cheese. This mid-day repast sets us back under 15$.

I was a regular visitor to the “Bones” when it was out in the West Shore – initial impressions were: “This is the best stuff I have put in my mouth…” over time some of the small things started to slip – but it was not the meat. I loved ribs. And I do have one or two favorite recipes I do at home – The long marinade grilled ribs that I do at home I am particularly proud of – but this isn’t about me. “Bones cook shack” does the meat quite well – where it falls off the bone for me are in the sides and some of the foundation items… like the bread. Ah. The bread. Here is the thing folks – if you are offering things like hush puppies, fried oysters, and good ole deep baked beans and Po’ Boys… well get the ingredients right.

To me (and this is just my opinion) the fried oyster basket tasted suspiciously like previously frozen bad boys from CostCo. And the cocktail sauce on the side seemed like it came out of a bottle. If it did not come out of a bottle, fine – at least formulate it like it is unique and attention getting… not like it was done on the cheap with too few good ingredients. I had a Oyster fry up at the “Crow and Gate” pub south or Nanaimo near Cedar, B.C. yesterday. 6 plump oysters fried to perfection served with two kinds of salad, a home made tartar sauce, a fresh but mass produced large dinner roll and a pad of butter. The Oysters from the Crow and Gate are light years ahead of the somewhat overcooked mini-oyster nuggets that “Bones” tries to pass off as an appetizer.

To their credit, “Bones Cook Shack” does a lot of things… well, OK – but they do not leave me gasping for joy. My thought is that perhaps they are trying to do too much with the space that they have – and it is a big space.
In all visits I have found the service to be spot on, the wait staff are well informed, knowledgeable and friendly. So, it is not about what’s happening on the floor – it is a bit of a disconnect in the kitchen – perhaps with the quality of some of the supplies.

In summary, I think that Smoken Bones Cook Shack could be consistent and amazing. Their signature meats are generally pretty good – well prepared, sauced and presentation. The most common complaint that I have heard that I do not necessarily agree with is with the plating… or the lack of it. I have heard it said that everything is served in plastic containers on wax paper – have not noticed this particularly – nor would it bother me if they did.

In comparing the two; PIG BBQ and Smoken Bones Cook Shack… it has to be acknowledged that they are two distinctly different “beasts” – and in the end analysis, PIG wins by not trying to be too many things with too many big ideas. The meat is tasty and is presented commensurate with the environment in which the products are prepared and delivered.

How could Smoken Bones Cook Shack step up? A: Take a good look at the menu. Trim it a bit – maybe a couple of items – or rotate some things and do them with a bit more authenticity and a dollop more pizzazz.
B: Step up on the bread. Bake it yourself if possible. Nothing destroys an Oyster Po’ Boy sandwich or pulled pork than dull tasting factory bread.
C: A message for all restaurants – outsource your sauces and breads at your peril. Think we do not notice? We do.

Colin Newell is a Victoria resident, IT Guy and food/drink writer – his writing has graced the internet since 1995

  1. Hey Colin, great write up and thank you for taking the time to speak your opinion. We always want to encourage opinions and suggestions from our awesome customers.

    I did want to mention that we get our bread baked daily from a local place out in Metchosin called The Royal Bay Bakery (

    As much as we would LOVE to make everything that leaves our kitchen in-house (and we do make almost all of it), there is simply not enough space to be our own bakery. Our kitchen is pretty tight for our crew and bakery ovens would just never fit.

    Just wanted to say our peace…Thanks again!

    Elizabeth Nyland    Jun 13, 02:28 pm    #
  2. Thank you for your thoughts – all part of constructive criticism – we try very hard to be hard, firm and gentle at the same time – no point being crazy mean spirited like some of those anonymous blogs and reports on UrbanSpoon…
    Again, thanks!
    I will be back.

    colin    Jun 13, 04:53 pm    #
  3. I don’t know what happened to Bones; they were great the first couple of times when at their original location. Things seemed to go downhill after that.
    I was surprised that they had the money to move to Victoria, although I’m sure the clientele is more numerous.

    As for Pig, I can’t agree with you on the food or the ambiance. Very noisy and loud. Blame the music played at ‘11’ and all the hard surfaces.

    After 2 visits, I thought the food quality varied somewhat.

    Considering the astonishingly high prices at both eateries, I expect a lot better and won’t be visiting either place again.

    Jed Sutherland    Jun 14, 06:19 pm    #
  4. I don’t know what happens to restaurants after the bloom of success or maybe its a Victoria thang? So here’s my 2-cents worth or maybe I should say nickels worth:

    a.) Smokin’ Bones Cookshack, formerly of Langwood/Colford, now bringing the bones to Victoria. Sad but true, but out of the gate first may not have been the best bet for the ‘Bones. Slow and steady sometimes makes for a better strategy especially in the food industry.

    Once upon a time, I heard fabulous raves about Smokin’ Bones so made a pact with my family’s meager budget that my meat-devouring teenie-bopper son, Adam and foodie cookin’ daughter, Bo ( take a Westshore hike and try it out. Makin’ it an occasion helps so we decided to celebrate the boy’s birthday a couple of years ago. Smokin’ was smokin’ with a great menu, quirky southern BBQ and cookin’ touches. We noticed that the line up for take-out was crazy and although we were plannin’ to eat in, it was pleasant to know that we could always count on ordering for a picnic plan out to Sooke Pot Holes, if we lasted long enough! Makin’ great ribs in an art form, corn bread, okra, and all the rest. The jazz playin’ and although the decor a bit on the blah side, the service was superb. So what happened? Dunno, but a few months later bookin’ a goin’ away dinner party for 14 people you think we would be honored guests bringing in some $$$ bucks, but for some reason they booked our table to table sitting in the middle of the restaurant through the main thorough-fare where everyone had to walk through to their booths. Most of the meals were great, especially the vegetarioso fare for our vegetarian pals. However, one gal got her gumbo barely warm and bland to boot…yuch!

    Always one to realize every eatery has its off days, a few months later doing a Saturday wander with a new friend, we went over to the ‘Shack for lunch. VERY bad idea! Got the wrong order, and then the cream soup was cool with a nice thick skin of gunk on top. My friend ordered the pulled pork sandwich and got beef. The waitress was clearly flustered because she ordered our meal but the kitchen didn’t bother to read her instructions. I was really disappointed but buddy told me this was common expectations for Victoria!

    2.) PIG! So far so good, except for the noise and prices, but hey, someone has to make a living! BBQ spaghetti? Yay! I loved it on View and love it on Johnson! Better yet, the PIG van is really the way to go…trying it on at Gottacon and hope to see it around more this summer.

    How ‘bout everyone get their act together and really listen to their customers! If you can’t keep it consistent, simplify and do it better. Cut out the stuff on the menu that doesn’t work, and work it. PS? Selling expensive soda really ticks me off…get a Soda Machine and give your clientele a break on the expensive sugar water!

    Lou-lou-rraine Pawlivsky-Love    Jun 17, 07:19 am    #
  5. Your pic of the sizzling and yummy ribs alone is captivating. Thumbs up!
    Editor: Thank you - link placement deleted - no free ads.
    Normy    May 31, 11:04 pm    #

Comment Rules

We welcome all kinds of comments on the content herein - Have fun! No spam please or commercial links! We will out you!

  Textile help